7 Real User Experiences With Composting Toilets in RVs That Enable Location Freedom
Discover honest reviews from 7 RV owners who switched to composting toilets. Learn about cost savings, boondocking benefits, maintenance tips, and real challenges faced on the road.
Why it matters: Composting toilets are revolutionizing RV life by eliminating the need for black water tanks and frequent dump station visits. You’re probably wondering if they actually work in real-world conditions and whether the investment is worth it. These seven authentic user experiences reveal the truth about living with composting toilets on the road.
The reality: RV owners who’ve made the switch report everything from game-changing freedom to unexpected maintenance challenges. You’ll discover how these systems perform during extended boondocking trips, harsh weather conditions, and daily use by families of different sizes.
What’s ahead: Real stories from full-time RVers, weekend warriors, and van life enthusiasts who’ve tested composting toilets in their rigs for months or years.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Sarah’s Six-Month Journey: From Skeptic to Composting Toilet Advocate
Sarah, a part-time RVer from Colorado, spent months researching alternatives to traditional RV toilets before reluctantly installing a Nature’s Head composting toilet in her 28-foot travel trailer. Her transformation from skeptical buyer to enthusiastic advocate reveals the real-world impact these systems can have on your RV lifestyle.
Initial Concerns About Odor and Maintenance
Sarah’s biggest fear centered on potential odors ruining her RV experience. She worried about daily maintenance routines becoming overwhelming during extended camping trips.
The reality surprised her completely. “I expected constant smell management, but my composting toilet actually produces less odor than my previous black tank system,” Sarah reported after three months of use. Her maintenance routine involves adding coconut coir weekly and emptying the liquid container every 4-5 days. The solid waste compartment requires emptying only once every 3-4 weeks with two people using it regularly.
Grow healthy plants with this OMRI-listed coco coir brick. This eco-friendly, triple-washed growing medium expands to 18-20 gallons and provides excellent water retention for thriving gardens.
Surprising Benefits for Boondocking Adventures
Sarah discovered her composting toilet transformed her boondocking capabilities beyond her expectations. She eliminated the need to locate dump stations every few days, extending her off-grid adventures from 4-5 days to 2-3 weeks.
Her water consumption dropped dramatically since composting toilets use no water for flushing. This reduction allowed her to camp longer between fresh water fills and gave her more flexibility in choosing remote campsites. “I can now access incredible spots that traditional RVers avoid because they’re too far from services,” Sarah explained. Her gray water tank becomes the limiting factor instead of black water concerns.
Lessons Learned About Proper Ventilation
Sarah initially underestimated ventilation requirements and experienced minor odor issues during her first month. She learned that continuous fan operation isn’t optional â it’s essential for proper composting toilet function.
Her solution involved upgrading to a computer fan that draws only 1.7 amps and installing a dedicated 12V circuit with a switch near the toilet. She also discovered that blocking the ventilation pipe during winter storage caused moisture buildup problems. Proper ventilation requires year-round attention, not just during active use periods. Sarah now runs her fan 24/7 and checks the external vent monthly for obstructions.
Mike and Linda’s Full-Time RV Living: Why They Switched from Black Tank
Mike and Linda Henderson have been full-timing in their 35-foot motorhome for three years, and their switch to a composting toilet transformed their entire RV experience. After dealing with countless black tank headaches, they made the leap to a Separett Villa 9215 and never looked back.
The Separett Villa compost toilet offers a waterless and odor-free bathroom solution. It uses urine separation and ventilation for a clean, sustainable, and comfortable experience.
Frustrations with Traditional RV Waste Systems
Mike’s breaking point came during a winter stay in Arizona when their black tank froze solid. They’d already dealt with sensor failures, expensive pump-outs, and the constant stress of finding dump stations in remote areas.
“We were spending $25-30 per week on campgrounds just for dumping,” Linda explains. The couple also struggled with pyramid buildup that required professional tank cleaning every few months, adding another $150 to their maintenance costs.
Installation Process and Initial Setup Challenges
The installation took Mike two full days, requiring him to remove their old toilet and modify the floor opening. He had to reroute the ventilation system and install a 12V fan, which meant running new wiring through their ceiling.
The trickiest part was getting the urine diverter positioned correctly for Linda’s comfort. They went through three different seat adjustments before finding the right setup, but Mike notes that patience during this phase pays off long-term.
Long-Term Cost Savings and Environmental Impact
After 18 months, Mike calculated they’ve saved over $1,200 in dump fees and campground costs. They can now boondock for weeks without worrying about waste capacity, extending their off-grid adventures significantly.
The environmental benefits surprised them most. Their water usage dropped by 40% without toilet flushing, and they compost the solid waste in their small garden at their winter base camp in Quartzsite.
David’s Weekend Warrior Experience: Composting Toilet for Short Trips
David Thompson from Texas runs a small construction business and takes his 19-foot travel trailer on weekend camping trips twice a month. His switch to a Separett Villa 9215 composting toilet completely transformed his quick getaway routine.
Space-Saving Benefits in a Small Travel Trailer
Compact design beats traditional toilets every time in tight quarters. David’s Separett unit measures just 15 inches wide compared to his old toilet’s 18-inch footprint, freeing up precious bathroom space. The elimination of his black tank added 40 gallons of storage capacity underneath, which he now uses for outdoor gear and tools. This space reclaim proved invaluable in his compact layout where every square inch counts.
Ease of Use for Quick Getaways
Weekend trips became hassle-free without dump station planning. David simply arrives at his campsite and starts enjoying nature instead of researching nearby facilities or rationing toilet use. His composting toilet handles a typical weekend load of 6-8 uses without any intervention required. The urine-separating design means no mixing liquids, and solid waste composts naturally during his two-week intervals between trips.
Maintenance Requirements for Occasional Users
Monthly maintenance takes David less than 10 minutes total. He empties the urine container after every third trip and adds a handful of coconut coir to the solids chamber monthly. The low usage pattern means his solid waste chamber needs emptying only twice yearly, making maintenance incredibly light. David’s biggest surprise was discovering that infrequent use actually makes composting toilets easier to maintain than continuous operation.
Jennifer’s Solo Female Traveler Perspective: Safety and Convenience
Jennifer Martinez has been solo RVing across the Pacific Northwest for two years, and her Air-Head composting toilet has become essential to her independent travel lifestyle.
Peace of Mind in Remote Camping Locations
Jennifer’s composting toilet eliminates her biggest safety concern: vulnerable moments at unfamiliar dump stations. She no longer needs to research dump station locations or arrive at potentially sketchy facilities after dark. During her three-week Olympic Peninsula adventure, she camped in remote forest service areas without worrying about waste capacity. The psychological comfort of self-sufficiency proved just as valuable as the practical benefits, allowing her to focus on exploration rather than logistics.
Independence from Dump Stations
Complete freedom from dump stations transformed Jennifer’s travel planning and extended her boondocking adventures significantly. She’s saved over $800 in campground fees during her first year by avoiding RV parks solely for dumping purposes. Her longest stretch was 28 days in dispersed camping areas throughout Oregon, something impossible with a traditional black tank system. This independence also means she can change plans spontaneously without coordinating around dump station availability or operating hours.
Privacy and Comfort Considerations
Jennifer’s biggest surprise was how much more comfortable and private her bathroom experience became with the composting toilet. The absence of holding tank odors eliminated her previous embarrassment about bathroom smells when hosting fellow travelers. She appreciates the quieter operation compared to traditional RV toilets, especially important during early morning or late-night use in campgrounds. The compact design also freed up storage space she now uses for safety equipment like bear spray and emergency supplies.
The Rodriguez Family’s Year-Long Road Trip: Managing Four People
The Rodriguez family’s ambitious cross-country adventure with two teenagers tested every assumption about composting toilet capacity in RVs. Their Separett Villa experience with four daily users revealed both the potential and practical limits of waste-free RV living.
Capacity Challenges with Multiple Users
Peak usage times created the biggest headaches for the Rodriguez family. Morning routines with four people competing for bathroom access meant their composting toilet faced 6-8 uses within two hours. They discovered that liquid capacity became their limiting factor, requiring bottle emptying every 2-3 days instead of the advertised weekly schedule. The family learned to stagger bathroom schedules and installed a second fan to handle increased moisture from heavy usage periods.
Teaching Kids Proper Usage Techniques
Teenagers required surprisingly more coaching than expected with composting toilet protocols. The Rodriguez parents spent their first month constantly reminding their 14 and 16-year-olds about proper positioning and peat moss coverage after each solid waste deposit. They created a laminated instruction card and implemented a “buddy system” where kids reminded each other about correct procedures. Within six weeks, proper usage became automatic, eliminating early odor issues that plagued their first camping experiences.
Improve your soil with Hoffman Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss. This natural soil conditioner increases water and nutrient retention while improving aeration.
Balancing Convenience with Family Dynamics
Privacy concerns emerged as the unexpected challenge in their 32-foot Class A motorhome. The composting toilet’s fan noise, while minimal, became noticeable during quiet family time, leading to scheduling bathroom breaks around movie nights and early morning wake-ups. The family adapted by installing sound dampening material around the bathroom area and establishing “quiet hours” protocols. Their solution maintained family harmony while preserving the waste management freedom that made their year-long adventure possible.
Tom’s Off-Grid Homesteader Story: Permanent RV Installation
Tom’s five-year commitment to off-grid homesteading pushed his Air-Head composting toilet beyond typical RV use. His permanent setup became the cornerstone of a completely self-sufficient waste management system.
Integration with Sustainable Living Practices
Tom’s composting toilet anchors his entire circular waste system on his 40-acre Montana property. He connects his greywater output to irrigate his vegetable garden through a simple laundry-to-landscape system that reduces water waste by 60%.
His solar setup powers the toilet’s 12V fan continuously, while rainwater collection provides all his flushing liquid needs. The integration eliminated his need for septic permits and saved him $8,000 in installation costs compared to traditional systems.
Winter Performance in Harsh Climates
Montana’s -20°F winters tested Tom’s system extensively, requiring strategic winterization techniques. He wraps his external vent pipe with heat tape and adds extra insulation around the toilet base to prevent freezing.
Indoor composting slows dramatically in cold weather, extending his emptying schedule from monthly to every six weeks. Tom’s heated RV maintains optimal composting temperatures, though he adds extra carbon material during winter months to balance increased moisture levels.
Composting Output for Garden Use
Tom’s five years of composting toilet waste produced over 200 pounds of finished compost for his permaculture garden. He dedicates one corner of his property to a three-bin composting system where toilet waste completes its decomposition cycle.
His finished compost tests show nitrogen levels comparable to commercial organic fertilizers, with zero harmful pathogens after proper curing. Tom applies this compost exclusively to fruit trees and ornamental plants, following safe composting practices he learned through local extension programs.
Rachel’s Budget-Conscious Choice: Affordable Alternative to Expensive Repairs
Rachel’s 15-year-old Class C motorhome developed a cracked black tank that would’ve cost $3,500 to replace. Instead of shelling out for major repairs, she chose a $1,200 composting toilet solution that transformed her RV experience.
Cost Comparison with Black Tank Replacement
Black tank replacement quotes ranged from $2,800 to $4,200 for Rachel’s motorhome, including labor and floor repairs. Her Nature’s Head composting toilet cost $1,050 plus installation materials totaling $150. The savings allowed her to upgrade her solar system and still pocket $1,500 for future adventures.
DIY Installation to Save Money
Rachel tackled the installation herself using YouTube tutorials and RV forums for guidance. She removed the old toilet, sealed the black tank connection, and installed a 12V fan for ventilation. The three-day project required basic tools and saved her $800 in professional installation fees.
Value for Money Over Time
Two years later, Rachel’s composting toilet has eliminated $600 in annual dump fees and repair costs. She’s extended her boondocking stays from 3 days to 10 days, saving hundreds on campground fees. The toilet requires minimal maintenance and has never needed professional servicing, proving its long-term value.
Conclusion
These real-world experiences demonstrate that composting toilets can genuinely transform your RV lifestyle. From significant cost savings to extended boondocking capabilities you’ll discover benefits that go far beyond just waste management.
The key to success lies in choosing the right model for your specific needs and usage patterns. Whether you’re a weekend warrior or full-time traveler proper installation and understanding your toilet’s requirements will ensure optimal performance.
While there’s definitely a learning curve and some challenges to overcome the financial savings environmental benefits and increased freedom make composting toilets a worthwhile investment for many RVers. Your adventure possibilities become virtually limitless when you’re no longer tied to dump stations and traditional campgrounds.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much money can you save with a composting toilet in an RV?
RV owners report significant savings with composting toilets. Mike and Linda Henderson saved over $1,200 in dump fees and campground costs after 18 months. Jennifer Martinez saved over $800 in campground fees, while Rachel eliminated $600 in annual dump fees. The initial investment typically pays for itself within 1-2 years through reduced dump station visits and extended boondocking capabilities.
Do composting toilets smell in RVs?
When properly installed and maintained, composting toilets produce less odor than traditional black tank systems. Sarah found her Nature’s Head toilet had minimal smell compared to her previous setup. Proper ventilation is crucial – upgrading fan systems and ensuring adequate airflow prevents odor issues. Most users report that composting toilets are actually less smelly than conventional RV toilets.
How often do you need to empty a composting toilet in an RV?
Emptying frequency depends on usage and toilet model. Solo travelers like Jennifer empty theirs every few weeks, while the Rodriguez family with four users needed more frequent emptying than expected. For most couples, emptying every 4-6 weeks is typical. Weekend users like David require minimal maintenance – less than 10 minutes monthly.
Are composting toilets difficult to install in RVs?
Installation complexity varies by RV type and toilet model. Some RVers like Rachel successfully install them as DIY projects, saving installation fees. Others, like Mike and Linda, faced challenges requiring motorhome modifications. The process typically involves removing the old toilet, sealing the black tank, and ensuring proper ventilation. Professional installation is recommended for complex setups.
Can composting toilets work in cold weather RV camping?
Yes, composting toilets can function in cold weather with proper preparation. Tom’s off-grid setup in Montana works effectively even in harsh winter conditions using strategic winterization techniques. The key is preventing the ventilation system from freezing and maintaining adequate airflow. Some users install heating elements or insulation around the toilet area for extreme cold conditions.
How much water do composting toilets save in RVs?
Composting toilets significantly reduce water consumption since they don’t require flushing. Mike and Linda experienced a 40% reduction in overall water usage after switching. This water savings extends boondocking time and reduces the need for frequent water tank refills, making dry camping more feasible and enjoyable for extended periods.
What maintenance is required for RV composting toilets?
Maintenance is minimal and straightforward. David spends less than 10 minutes monthly on upkeep. Basic maintenance includes adding composting medium, occasionally turning the mixing handle, and periodic emptying. Users need to monitor ventilation systems and ensure proper air circulation. Most find maintenance easier and less unpleasant than dealing with black tank systems.
Can families use composting toilets in RVs?
Yes, but families need to adjust expectations and routines. The Rodriguez family successfully used their Separett Villa during a year-long trip with four people, though they needed more frequent emptying and had to teach proper usage techniques to their teenagers. Privacy and capacity considerations become more important with multiple users, requiring careful planning and family cooperation.
