7 Factors to Consider When Choosing a Water Heater That Save Money
Discover the 7 key factors for choosing the perfect water heater for your home. Compare costs, efficiency, and features to make the best decision for your budget and needs.
Why it matters: Your water heater accounts for nearly 20% of your home’s energy costs and choosing the wrong one can lead to years of inefficiency and frustration.
Boil water quickly and safely with the Cosori Electric Kettle. It features a stainless steel filter and spout for pure-tasting water, plus automatic shut-off for added safety.
The big picture: With tankless electric and gas models flooding the market alongside traditional storage tanks you’re facing more options than ever before.
What’s next: Seven key factors will help you cut through the noise and select a water heater that matches your household’s specific needs and budget.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Size and Capacity Requirements
Getting the right size water heater prevents cold showers and wasted energy costs. Your household’s hot water needs determine whether you’ll need a compact unit or a high-capacity system.
Household Size and Usage Patterns
A family of four typically needs 50-80 gallons of hot water daily, but your actual usage varies based on shower length, dishwasher frequency, and laundry habits. Track your peak usage times when multiple family members shower consecutively or when you’re running appliances simultaneously. Single-person households often thrive with 30-40 gallon tanks, while large families with teenagers may need 80+ gallon capacity to avoid running out during busy morning routines.
Peak Demand Calculations
Calculate your peak hour demand by adding up simultaneous hot water uses during your busiest time. A standard shower uses 2.5 gallons per minute, dishwashers need 6-16 gallons per cycle, and washing machines require 7-25 gallons depending on load size. If two people shower while the dishwasher runs, you’re looking at 25-35 gallons in one hour. This peak demand calculation determines your minimum tank size or flow rate requirements.
This Midea built-in dishwasher offers a slim design with an 8-place setting capacity. It features six wash programs, including a heated dry function, to efficiently clean all your dishware.
Tank Size vs. Tankless Options
Traditional tank heaters store 30-120 gallons but take up significant floor space, while tankless units mount on walls and heat water on-demand. Tanks work well for consistent, predictable usage patterns and cost less upfront. Tankless systems excel when you have limited space, irregular usage, or want endless hot water, but they require higher gas lines or electrical upgrades and cost 2-3 times more initially.
Maintain a consistent aquarium temperature with the HITOP 50W submersible heater. Featuring adjustable temperature control and durable quartz glass, it's easy to install with included suction cups.
Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs
Your water heater’s efficiency directly impacts your monthly utility bills and long-term savings. Understanding these ratings helps you make smart financial decisions.
Energy Factor Ratings
Energy Factor (EF) ratings measure how efficiently your water heater converts energy into hot water. Higher EF ratings mean lower operating costs over time.
Gas water heaters typically range from 0.67 to 0.95 EF, while electric models score between 0.90 to 0.95. Tankless units often exceed 0.95 EF because they don’t lose heat through storage tank walls.
Get instant hot water where you need it with the Bosch Tronic 3000 T mini-tank water heater. Its 2.5-gallon capacity and easy installation eliminate waiting, and the premium glass-lined tank ensures lasting performance.
You’ll save approximately $30-50 annually for every 0.10 increase in EF rating on your utility bills.
Annual Operating Cost Estimates
Annual operating costs vary significantly between fuel types and efficiency levels. Natural gas units typically cost $200-400 per year to operate for average households.
Electric water heaters generally run $400-600 annually due to higher electricity rates in most regions. Heat pump water heaters offer the lowest operating costs at $150-250 per year despite higher upfront prices.
Calculate your specific costs using local utility rates and the yellow EnergyGuide label found on new units.
ENERGY STAR Certifications
ENERGY STAR certified water heaters meet strict efficiency guidelines set by the EPA. These models use 10-50% less energy than standard units depending on the technology.
Gas storage tank models need 0.67 EF minimum while electric tanks require 2.20 EF to earn certification. Tankless gas units must achieve 0.87 EF or higher for ENERGY STAR qualification.
You’ll typically recover the higher purchase price through energy savings within 3-5 years of installation.
Fuel Type and Availability
Your water heater’s fuel source determines both upfront costs and long-term operating expenses. Natural gas typically offers the lowest operating costs, while electric models provide reliable performance in any location.
Natural Gas vs. Electric Options
Natural gas water heaters cost 50-60% less to operate than electric units, saving homeowners $200-400 annually. Gas models heat water twice as fast as electric units and continue working during power outages. However, gas installation requires existing gas lines and proper ventilation, while electric units can be installed anywhere with adequate electrical service. Electric water heaters offer precise temperature control and don’t produce combustion gases, making them safer for tight spaces.
Propane and Oil Alternatives
Propane water heaters deliver similar performance to natural gas units but cost 2-3 times more to operate due to higher fuel prices. They’re ideal for rural areas without natural gas access and offer excellent energy efficiency ratings of 0.80-0.95 EF. Oil-fired water heaters work well in cold climates and integrate with existing oil heating systems. These units typically cost $300-500 annually to operate and require regular maintenance including annual cleaning and fuel delivery scheduling.
Local Utility Costs and Infrastructure
Check your local utility rates before selecting fuel types, as costs vary significantly by region. Natural gas averages $1.00-1.50 per therm nationally, while electricity ranges from $0.08-0.25 per kWh depending on your location. Contact your utility company to verify gas line availability and installation costs, which can range from $500-2,000 for new connections. Consider future fuel price trends in your area, as some regions are transitioning away from natural gas or offering rebates for electric heat pump water heaters.
Installation Space and Location
Your water heater’s location affects everything from installation costs to daily maintenance access. The space you choose determines which models you can install and how efficiently they’ll operate.
Physical Dimensions and Clearance Requirements
Tank water heaters need 6-12 inches of clearance on all sides for proper airflow and service access. Standard 40-50 gallon units measure 60-65 inches tall and 20-24 inches wide, requiring at least 3×4 feet of floor space. Tankless models mount on walls and need only 4 inches of clearance around the unit, making them ideal for closets, utility rooms, or basement installations where space is limited.
Ventilation Needs
Gas water heaters require direct venting to the outside through existing chimneys or dedicated vent pipes, with installation costs increasing $500-1,500 if new venting is needed. Electric units need no special ventilation but require adequate room ventilation to prevent moisture buildup. Tankless gas models use sealed combustion systems that can vent horizontally through exterior walls, offering more flexible installation options than traditional tank units.
Accessibility for Maintenance
Plan for routine service access by ensuring 18-24 inches of working space in front of your water heater for filter changes, anode rod replacement, and annual maintenance. Locations like cramped crawl spaces or tight closets create expensive service calls when technicians can’t easily reach components. Consider proximity to electrical panels and water shut-off valves, as emergency repairs often require quick access to both utilities.
Initial Purchase Price and Budget
Your budget determines which water heater types you can realistically consider and affects your long-term satisfaction with the purchase.
Upfront Equipment Costs
Traditional tank water heaters offer the most affordable entry point, ranging from $500-1,500 for standard 40-50 gallon units. Electric models typically cost $100-300 less than comparable gas versions due to simpler components.
Tankless water heaters require a larger initial investment, with electric units starting around $800-2,000 and gas models ranging from $1,200-3,500. High-efficiency condensing tankless units can exceed $4,000 but offer superior long-term performance.
Installation and Labor Expenses
Professional installation adds $500-1,500 to your total project cost, depending on complexity and local labor rates. Simple tank-to-tank replacements cost less, while switching fuel types or locations increases expenses significantly.
Tankless installations often require additional electrical upgrades, gas line modifications, or new venting systems. These changes can add $1,000-3,000 to installation costs, particularly when upgrading from tank systems.
Financing Options
Many utility companies offer rebates of $50-500 for ENERGY STAR certified models, reducing your upfront investment. Some manufacturers provide promotional financing with 0% interest for 12-24 months on qualifying purchases.
Home improvement loans and personal loans can spread costs over 2-7 years with fixed monthly payments. Consider the total interest costs when evaluating financing, as energy savings may offset loan payments over time.
Brand Reputation and Warranty Coverage
Choosing a water heater from a trusted manufacturer with comprehensive warranty protection helps ensure your investment performs reliably for years. Strong brand reputation and warranty coverage provide peace of mind and financial protection against potential equipment failures.
Manufacturer Reliability Records
Established manufacturers like Rheem AO Smith and Bradford White consistently earn top reliability ratings in industry studies. These brands typically show 85-95% customer satisfaction rates and maintain extensive service networks nationwide. Research manufacturer track records through consumer reports plumbing contractor reviews and warranty claim statistics. Look for companies with 50+ years of water heater manufacturing experience and strong financial stability ratings.
Warranty Terms and Length
Standard water heater warranties range from 6-12 years with premium models offering extended coverage options. Tank warranties typically cover different components separately – tanks receive 6-12 year coverage while parts get 1-3 years. Tankless units often include 10-15 year heat exchanger warranties with 5-year parts coverage. Read warranty terms carefully as some require professional installation and annual maintenance to remain valid.
Customer Service and Support
Top manufacturers provide 24/7 customer support toll-free numbers and comprehensive online resources including troubleshooting guides. Quality brands maintain extensive authorized dealer networks and certified technician programs for reliable service access. Check manufacturer websites for local service availability parts availability timelines and technical support quality ratings. Companies with dedicated customer service teams and live chat support typically resolve issues faster than those relying solely on automated systems.
Maintenance Requirements and Lifespan
Understanding maintenance needs and expected lifespan helps you budget for ongoing costs and plan for eventual replacement. Different water heater types require varying levels of attention and offer different service lives.
Routine Maintenance Needs
Tank water heaters need annual flushing to remove sediment buildup and anode rod replacement every 3-5 years. You’ll also need to test the temperature relief valve annually and inspect for leaks around connections.
Tankless units require descaling every 1-2 years depending on water hardness and filter cleaning every few months. Professional maintenance visits typically cost $150-300 annually but prevent costly repairs.
Expected Service Life
Traditional tank heaters last 8-12 years with proper maintenance while tankless models typically operate for 15-20 years. Heat pump water heaters average 10-15 years but their components may need replacement sooner.
Gas units generally have shorter lifespans than electric models due to combustion stress. Hard water areas reduce lifespan by 2-3 years regardless of type due to mineral buildup and corrosion.
Replacement Part Availability
Major manufacturers like Rheem and AO Smith maintain parts availability for 10+ years after discontinuation. Tankless units may require specialized components that cost more but are readily available through authorized dealers.
Generic parts work for basic tank components like elements and thermostats but proprietary parts for advanced features may be harder to source. Consider parts availability when choosing between mainstream and boutique brands.
Conclusion
Your water heater choice will impact your daily comfort and monthly budget for years to come. By carefully evaluating these seven factors you’ll find a system that perfectly matches your household’s needs while maximizing long-term value.
Remember that the cheapest upfront option isn’t always the most economical choice. Focus on balancing initial costs with ongoing efficiency savings and maintenance requirements. A well-researched decision today means reliable hot water and lower utility bills tomorrow.
Take time to compare different models within your preferred category and don’t hesitate to consult with qualified professionals during the selection process. Your investment in the right water heater will pay dividends through improved performance reduced energy costs and peace of mind for years ahead.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much of my home’s energy costs come from water heating?
Water heating accounts for nearly 20% of your home’s total energy costs, making it one of the largest energy expenses in most households. Selecting an efficient water heater can significantly reduce your monthly utility bills and provide substantial long-term savings.
How much hot water does a typical family of four need daily?
A family of four typically requires 50-80 gallons of hot water per day. However, actual usage varies based on factors like shower length, appliance use, and household habits. Track your peak usage times to determine your specific household’s hot water needs.
What’s the difference between tank and tankless water heaters?
Enjoy endless hot water on demand with the EcoSmart ECO 11. This compact, energy-efficient tankless water heater uses self-modulating technology to deliver consistent performance while saving space and energy.
Tank water heaters store 30-120 gallons of hot water and take up more floor space, while tankless units heat water on-demand and are wall-mountable. Tank systems cost less upfront but tankless models save space and provide endless hot water, though at a higher initial investment.
What is an Energy Factor (EF) rating?
Energy Factor (EF) ratings measure how efficiently a water heater converts energy into hot water. Higher ratings mean lower operating costs. Gas units typically range from 0.67-0.95 EF, electric models score 0.90-0.95, and tankless units often exceed 0.95 EF.
How much can I save annually with a higher EF rating?
For every 0.10 increase in EF rating, homeowners can save approximately $30-50 annually on utility bills. This adds up to significant savings over the water heater’s lifespan, often recovering higher upfront costs within 3-5 years.
Which fuel type offers the lowest operating costs?
Natural gas typically offers the lowest operating costs at $200-400 annually, compared to electric water heaters at $400-600 per year. Heat pump water heaters provide the most savings at $150-250 annually, despite higher purchase prices.
How much space do I need for water heater installation?
Tank water heaters need significant floor space and clearance for airflow, while tankless models are compact and wall-mountable. Gas units require proper ventilation and direct venting. Ensure adequate working space around any unit for maintenance access.
What are typical upfront costs for different water heater types?
Traditional tank water heaters offer the most affordable entry point, while tankless models require larger investments. Electric models generally cost less than gas versions. Professional installation adds significantly to total costs, especially for tankless systems requiring modifications.
Which water heater brands are most reliable?
Trusted manufacturers include Rheem, AO Smith, and Bradford White, which typically have high customer satisfaction rates and strong reliability records. Choose brands with extensive service networks and 24/7 customer support for reliable performance and quick issue resolution.
How long do different water heater types last?
Traditional tank water heaters typically last 8-12 years, while tankless models operate for 15-20 years. Lifespan depends on maintenance, water quality, and usage patterns. Proper maintenance can extend service life and optimize performance throughout the unit’s lifespan.
What maintenance do water heaters require?
Tank water heaters need annual flushing and anode rod replacement every 3-5 years. Tankless units require descaling every 1-2 years and filter cleaning every few months. Regular professional maintenance helps prevent breakdowns and maintains efficiency ratings.
Are ENERGY STAR certified water heaters worth it?
ENERGY STAR certified models use 10-50% less energy than standard units and meet strict EPA efficiency guidelines. The higher purchase price is typically recovered through energy savings within 3-5 years, making them cost-effective long-term investments.
