6 Best Self-Contained RV Toilets For Travel Trailers That Support Self-Reliance

You’re five days into a boondocking trip, miles from the nearest town, and the last thing you want to worry about is a full black tank. True self-reliance in a travel trailer isn’t just about solar panels and water tanks; it’s about managing your waste independently and efficiently. Choosing the right self-contained toilet is one of the most critical decisions you’ll make for comfortable, long-term off-grid travel.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Selecting Your Ideal Off-Grid RV Toilet System

The toilet conversation is never glamorous, but it’s fundamental to your freedom on the road. Your choice boils down to a core trade-off: convenience versus capacity. A system that feels familiar like a traditional toilet often requires more resources (water, chemicals) and more frequent servicing. A system that maximizes your time off-grid demands a more hands-on, and sometimes unfamiliar, process.

There are three main categories to consider. Composting toilets separate liquids and solids, require no water, and offer the longest service intervals. Cassette toilets offer a built-in, plumbed experience but with a small, removable waste tank you empty manually. Finally, portable toilets are the simplest, cheapest entry point, acting as self-contained units you can place anywhere, but they have the smallest capacity.

Forget the idea of a single "best" toilet. The right choice depends entirely on your travel style. Are you a weekend warrior who is never far from a dump station, or a full-timer who spends weeks in the wilderness? Your answer dictates whether you should prioritize portability, capacity, or a water-saving design.

Nature’s Head: The Gold Standard for Composting

When people talk about composting toilets for RVs, the Nature’s Head is almost always the first name mentioned. There’s a good reason for that. It’s built like a tank, has a proven track record, and its design is straightforward and effective for long-term off-grid use.

The system works by diverting urine into a removable bottle at the front, while solids go into a larger rear compartment mixed with a composting medium like coco coir or peat moss. A simple hand crank agitates the solids after each use, promoting aerobic decomposition and preventing odor. A small 12V fan runs continuously, venting any moisture and smell to the outside. This separation is the key; keeping liquids and solids apart is what eliminates sewage odor almost entirely.

The major benefit here is capacity. The urine bottle typically needs emptying every 2-4 days, which is simple and discreet. The solids bin, however, can last two people 4-6 weeks before needing to be emptied. This completely changes the calculus of boondocking, freeing you from the typical 5-7 day limit of a traditional black tank. The trade-off is the initial cost and the manual process of emptying the solids, which, while not difficult, is a deal-breaker for some.

Thetford C220: The Integrated Cassette Solution

For those who want a self-contained system without straying too far from a traditional RV setup, the cassette toilet is the answer. The Thetford C220 series is a perfect example of this integrated approach. It looks and feels like a standard RV toilet, with a swiveling bowl and an electric flush, but instead of feeding a large black tank, it deposits waste into a portable "cassette" tank hidden underneath.

This cassette, typically around 5 gallons, is accessed via a small service door on the exterior of your travel trailer. When it’s full, you simply slide it out, wheel it to a dump station or public restroom, and empty it. It’s a clean, well-designed system that contains the mess and makes disposal far more flexible than maneuvering an entire RV over a dump station.

The appeal is the blend of convenience and self-containment. You get a familiar flush and a permanently installed fixture. However, you are still dealing with chemically-treated black water, and that 5-gallon capacity means you’ll be emptying it every 2-4 days with two people. It also consumes fresh water for flushing, which is a critical resource when you’re off-grid. It’s an excellent solution for those who value a conventional experience but want to avoid a permanent black tank.

Air Head Toilet: Compact Urine-Diverting Design

The Air Head is the Nature’s Head‘s main competitor in the composting world, and the choice between them often comes down to fit and finish. Where the Nature’s Head is boxy and utilitarian, the Air Head features a more compact, rounded design that can be a better fit for the tight, oddly shaped bathrooms common in smaller travel trailers and van conversions.

Functionally, it’s very similar: it diverts urine, uses a crank to agitate solids in a composting medium, and relies on a 12V fan for ventilation. The key differences are in the details. The Air Head’s smaller footprint and varied mounting options make it more versatile for custom builds. Some users also prefer its agitator design and find the overall construction to be slightly more robust.

The trade-offs are nearly identical to any composting toilet—a high upfront cost and a manual emptying process. The round bowl can also be less comfortable for some compared to the elongated bowl on the Nature’s Head. Ultimately, the Air Head is a fantastic, high-quality choice for anyone committed to waterless, long-term boondocking, especially when space is at a premium.

Thetford Porta Potti Curve: Portable Convenience

Sometimes, the simplest solution is the best one. The Thetford Porta Potti Curve is the modern evolution of the classic portable toilet, offering an affordable, no-installation-required option for ultimate flexibility. It’s a two-part system: the top half holds the freshwater for flushing and the toilet bowl, while the bottom half is a sealed, detachable waste tank.

Its greatest strength is its versatility. You can use it in a brand-new trailer that doesn’t have a bathroom built yet, keep it as an emergency backup, or even use it outside your rig. With a battery-powered flush and a comfortable seat height, it feels surprisingly civilized for a portable unit. When it’s full, you just separate the two halves and carry the lightweight waste tank to a proper disposal site.

Of course, the convenience comes at the cost of capacity. With a 5.5-gallon waste tank, a couple will need to empty it every few days. This makes it ideal for weekend trips or for solo travelers, but less practical for extended, full-time use unless you have very frequent access to dump facilities. It’s the undisputed king of low-cost, low-commitment self-containment.

Separett Tiny: A Waterless, Ventless Option

The Separett Tiny represents a different take on the urine-diverting toilet, designed with the aesthetics and constraints of modern tiny homes and high-end conversions in mind. Unlike traditional composting toilets that mix solids with a medium, the Separett is primarily a desiccating toilet. It focuses on drying out solid waste rather than composting it.

Its standout feature is its urine-diverting mechanism, which routes liquids out through a hose to your main gray water tank or a separate external container. Solids are collected in a bucket lined with a compostable bag. A small, quiet 12V fan runs constantly to pull moisture from the solids and vent it, which is key to its odorless operation. This bag-based system can make disposal incredibly simple—just tie it off and toss it in a trash receptacle where permitted.

The design is sleek and modern, but it comes with specific requirements. You must have a way to plumb the urine drain, and it needs a constant 12V power source for the fan. While it’s marketed as "ventless," the fan is still moving air and moisture, which has to go somewhere, typically into the RV’s existing vent stack or a small dedicated outlet. It’s a premium option for those seeking a waterless solution with a clean, simple disposal process.

Dometic 970 Series: Durable and Simple Portability

If the Thetford Porta Potti is the feature-rich portable option, the Dometic 970 Series is its rugged, no-nonsense cousin. This line of portable toilets is built for durability and simplicity, making it a favorite among overlanders, van lifers, and anyone who prioritizes reliability over bells and whistles.

The construction is noticeably robust, with strong latches securing the fresh and waste water tanks together to prevent leaks on bumpy roads. The operation is dead simple, often using a push-button or piston-pump flush that is less prone to failure than more complex battery-operated systems. Its biggest advantage during disposal is the extra-long, pivoting dump spout, which makes emptying the tank a much cleaner and more controlled process.

Like any portable toilet, the Dometic 970 has a limited capacity (usually 2.6 or 5 gallons) and requires frequent emptying. It’s not designed for a family of four on a week-long boondocking trip. But for a solo traveler or a couple on a short getaway, its bombproof build and practical design make it an incredibly dependable choice for simple, self-contained sanitation.

Key Factors for Your Self-Contained RV Toilet

Choosing the right toilet isn’t about finding the "best" one, but the best one for you. Your decision should be guided by an honest assessment of how you travel, where you go, and what you’re willing to handle. Break down your decision using these key factors.

First, consider Capacity vs. Emptying Frequency. A composting toilet’s solid tank can last for weeks, while a portable or cassette toilet will need attention every 2-5 days. If your goal is to stay off-grid for as long as possible, a composting toilet is the clear winner. If you’re mostly in campgrounds with facilities, the convenience of a cassette might be preferable.

Next, think about Disposal Logistics. This is a huge factor many people overlook.

• Composting (Solids): Can often be disposed of in a compostable bag in the regular trash (check local regulations).
• Composting (Liquids): Can be diluted and dispersed in nature (away from water sources) or dumped in a toilet.
• Cassette/Portable: Must be emptied into a proper dump station, septic system, or public toilet. You cannot dump this chemical-laden waste on the ground.

Finally, weigh Water Usage, Installation, and Budget. Composting and desiccating toilets use zero water, a massive advantage for boondocking. Cassette and portable toilets require freshwater for every flush. Installation can range from simply placing a portable unit on the floor to cutting vent holes and running 12V wiring for a composting model. Budgets reflect this, with portable toilets starting under $200 and high-end composting units exceeding $1,000. Your toilet choice should align with your water conservation strategy and your budget.

Ultimately, your RV toilet is a tool that enables your desired travel style. Don’t just buy the most popular model; choose the system that best resolves the fundamental tension between at-home convenience and off-grid freedom for the adventures you actually plan to have.