7 Best Plywood Types For Subfloor Replacement In Apartments For Quiet
Fix your creaky apartment floors with this plywood.
That faint creak from the floor above you isn’t just an old building settling. It’s a sign of a subfloor that’s flexing, rubbing, and transmitting every footstep. In the close quarters of apartment living, what lies beneath your feet is the unsung hero—or villain—of your daily peace and quiet. Choosing the right material isn’t just a construction detail; it’s an investment in tranquility.
A solid, quiet subfloor is the foundation for everything else. It separates you from your neighbors, dampens impact noise, and prevents the maddening squeaks that can ruin an otherwise peaceful home. The wrong choice can lead to years of audible footsteps, shifting furniture sounds, and a constant, low-level source of stress. Getting this one layer right is one of the most impactful decisions you can make for quality of life in a multi-family building.
This guide breaks down the best plywood options, moving beyond simple construction-grade choices to focus on what matters most in an apartment: density, stability, and sound dampening. We’ll look at the tradeoffs between cost, moisture resistance, and acoustic performance. The goal is to give you a clear framework for selecting a subfloor that creates a truly quiet and solid foundation for your home.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Find Your Best Plywood for a Quieter Apartment
Not all plywood sheets are created equal, especially when your primary goal is silence. The "best" option is a balance of your specific needs, from the moisture levels in a ground-floor unit to the budget for your renovation. The key is understanding that you’re not just building a floor; you’re engineering a sound barrier.
The core principle for a quiet subfloor is density and uniformity. Materials with fewer internal voids and more mass are simply better at stopping sound vibrations. This is why a cheap, knot-filled sheathing panel will always be noisier than a dense, engineered panel, even if they have the same thickness. Think of it as the difference between a hollow door and a solid-core one; the mass is what blocks the noise.
Before you choose, consider these factors: your budget, the room’s purpose (e.g., bathroom vs. bedroom), and your tolerance for future noise. A slightly higher upfront investment in a denser panel can pay dividends in peace and quiet for years. Remember, the subfloor is the most difficult layer to change later, so it pays to get it right the first time.
Advantech: Your Premium Squeak-Free Foundation
If your number one enemy is the dreaded floor squeak, Advantech is your champion. This isn’t traditional plywood; it’s a high-performance OSB (Oriented Strand Board) panel engineered specifically for subflooring. Its high density and advanced resin formula create an incredibly stiff and stable panel that resists flexing under load.
The magic of Advantech lies in its moisture resistance. Squeaks are often caused by wood swelling and shrinking with humidity changes, causing fasteners to loosen and panels to rub. Advantech is designed to prevent water absorption, ensuring it holds fasteners tight and maintains its shape. This dimensional stability is why it’s backed by a squeak-free guarantee when installed correctly.
While it comes at a premium price compared to standard plywood, the cost is often justified by the performance. For apartments where you have no control over the humidity in neighboring units or common areas, investing in a material that is inherently stable is a smart move. It’s the "set it and forget it" solution for a silent, solid floor.
Sturdi-Floor T&G: Your All-Around Performer
When you see "Sturdi-Floor," you’re looking at a performance-rated panel designed specifically for single-layer subflooring. These panels, often made as plywood or OSB, feature a tongue-and-groove (T&G) edge. This interlocking system is the key to its strength and quietness.
The T&G profile forces the panels to lock together, creating a single, monolithic surface that distributes weight more evenly and prevents the edges from moving independently. This dramatically reduces the potential for rubbing and squeaking between panels. It’s a simple but highly effective mechanical solution to a common noise problem.
Sturdi-Floor T&G panels offer a fantastic balance of performance and cost, making them a go-to for many builders. They provide a significant acoustic upgrade over basic square-edge sheathing without the premium cost of highly specialized panels. For most apartment renovations, a quality T&G plywood is the reliable, effective, and sensible choice.
CDX Plywood: Your Budget-Friendly, Solid Choice
This 23/32-inch thick, 5-ply CDX plywood sheathing panel, made in the USA, provides exceptional strength and durability for walls, roofs, and floors. Built to PS 2 standards with moisture-resistant glue and a square edge, it ensures reliable structural support for construction projects.
CDX plywood is the workhorse of the construction world, and for good reason. The letters tell you what you’re getting: one "C" grade face, one "D" grade face, and "X" for exterior glue. While the faces can have knots and imperfections, the exterior-grade glue gives it a decent resistance to moisture during the construction phase.
For quietness, CDX’s performance depends heavily on proper installation. Because it lacks a T&G profile, the seams between sheets are a potential source of movement and noise. To mitigate this, installers must use proper panel spacing, a high-quality subfloor adhesive, and an adequate fastening schedule. When paired with a good acoustic underlayment, CDX can provide a solid, quiet base on a tight budget.
Get superior sound reduction and moisture protection for your luxury vinyl, laminate, or wood floors with QuietWalk LV underlayment. Its compression-resistant design and integrated vapor barrier ensure lasting stability and prevent moisture damage.
The main tradeoff with CDX is its lower density and potential for internal voids compared to premium options. However, if your budget is the primary constraint, don’t dismiss it. A well-installed CDX subfloor is far superior to a poorly installed premium panel. It’s a testament to the fact that craftsmanship matters just as much as materials.
Marine-Grade Plywood for Ultimate Density & Quiet
This premium fir marine plywood is ideal for high-moisture environments. Its void-free construction and sanded surface ensure a smooth, seal-ready panel.
Let’s clear up a common misconception: marine-grade plywood is not waterproof. It is, however, made with waterproof glue and is virtually free of voids. The layers (plies) are made from high-quality wood, creating an incredibly dense, stable, and rigid panel.
This void-free construction is precisely what makes it an excellent choice for sound damping. Sound struggles to travel through dense, solid mass, and marine-grade plywood has that in spades. The absence of air pockets inside the panel means there are no weak spots for sound vibrations to pass through or for the panel to flex and creak.
While it’s one of the most expensive options and often overkill for a living room, marine-grade plywood is a superb choice for apartment bathrooms, laundry areas, or kitchens. In these spaces, its superior moisture resistance and acoustic density provide a double benefit, protecting against water damage while contributing to a quieter home.
Baltic Birch: Your Void-Free, High-End Option
Craft beautiful projects with 3mm Baltic Birch plywood, stronger than basswood. This B/BB grade wood is ideal for laser cutting, CNC, and wood burning, offering exceptional durability and a smooth surface.
Baltic Birch is often associated with high-end cabinetry and furniture, but its unique properties make it a phenomenal, if unconventional, subfloor material. Unlike traditional plywood, it’s made from multiple, equally thick layers of birch veneer. This creates a panel that is exceptionally stable, strong, and completely free of voids.
Similar to marine-grade, the density and void-free nature of Baltic Birch make it an acoustic powerhouse. Its uniform core provides a consistent and solid barrier to impact and airborne sound. The sheer stiffness of the material also means it is highly resistant to the kind of micro-flexing that eventually leads to squeaks and creaks.
The significant drawback is cost; Baltic Birch is a premium material and its price reflects that. It’s not a practical choice for an entire apartment floor. However, for a smaller area where acoustic isolation is critical—like a home office, a nursery, or the floor beneath a piano—it offers an unmatched level of stability and sound-deadening performance.
Huber Blue Plus: Your Moisture-Resistant Pick
Moisture is the silent enemy of a quiet floor. When subfloor panels absorb moisture, they swell, warp, and delaminate, leading to squeaks, pops, and an unstable feel underfoot. Huber Blue Plus is an engineered wood panel specifically designed to combat this with a proprietary water-resistant coating on the top surface and edges.
This protective coating is especially valuable during the renovation process when the subfloor might be exposed to spills, rain from an open window, or wet materials. By preventing moisture from penetrating the panel, particularly at the vulnerable T&G edges, it ensures the subfloor maintains its structural integrity and dimensional stability for the long haul.
For ground-floor apartments, units in humid climates, or any room with a higher risk of water exposure, Blue Plus is a smart upgrade. It provides peace of mind that goes beyond acoustics. It ensures the quiet foundation you build today won’t be compromised by an unexpected leak tomorrow.
Acoustical Plywood: Your Sound-Engineered Base
When maximum sound reduction is the non-negotiable goal, you turn to a specialized product. Acoustical plywood, like brands such as QuietRock or SilentPly, is an engineered panel designed from the ground up to stop sound. It typically features a constrained layer damping (CLD) system—a layer of viscoelastic polymer sandwiched between layers of wood.
Enhance your audio space with these 12" x 12" x 2" acoustic foam panels, designed to significantly reduce echo and noise. Their high-density, periodic groove structure effectively absorbs sound, ideal for studios, home theaters, and more.
This "goo" layer is the secret sauce. When sound waves hit the panel, they cause the polymer to shear and stretch, converting the sound energy into a tiny, imperceptible amount of heat. This process is incredibly effective at damping both impact noise (footsteps) and airborne noise (voices, music), achieving a high Sound Transmission Class (STC) rating in a single, thin panel.
This is the most expensive option per sheet, but it can solve profound noise issues that other materials can’t. If you’re dealing with a noisy neighbor below or creating a home theater or recording space, acoustical plywood is a direct, engineered solution to the problem. It replaces guesswork with proven acoustic science.
Choosing a subfloor is about more than just creating a flat surface for your flooring. It’s an active decision about the soundscape of your home. From the budget-friendly reliability of CDX to the engineered silence of acoustical panels, each option offers a different balance of cost, durability, and quiet. The key is to see the subfloor not as a passive structural element, but as the first and most important layer of your soundproofing system.
The quietest apartments are not built by accident. They are the result of intentional choices made at every layer, starting from the joists up. By investing wisely in a dense, stable, and properly installed subfloor, you are laying the groundwork for a more peaceful and private living space.
Ultimately, the best choice is the one that aligns with your budget and your specific needs for silence and stability. Think about the long-term value of a creak-free floor and the daily comfort of not hearing every footstep. A solid foundation is an investment you’ll appreciate every single day.
